SIGMETRICS SYMPOSIUM ON PARALLEL AND DISTRIBUTED TOOLS
MANUSCRIPT REVIEW FORM
A copy of this part of the review form will be sent to the author(s).
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
Paper Title:
Paper Authors:
REFEREE NAME:
(make sure to also put your name on the edited draft of the paper)
Please rate the paper from 5 (Excellent) to 1 (Unacceptable).
Originality:
Significance:
Technical strength:
Written presentation:
Relevance to symposium:
Your overall recommendation:
Please rate how confident you feel of your assessment (due to factors
such as closeness of topic to your area of expertise, level of detail
at which you evaluated paper, etc.).
Confidence in review:
5 = ``I really know this topic''
4 = ``I'm pretty well-versed in this topic''
3 = ``I know something about this topic''
2 = ``I understand what I read''
1 = ``I know someone who understands this topic''
0 = ``I'm totally clueless''
Reviewer:
Please give very detailed comments to explain your ratings and/or
to help the authors improve the paper.